Asthma was one of the top 20 diagnoses presenting to emergency departments in Australia in 2016/7. In this topic summary, people with severe asthma tell of their experiences once they had decided to seek treatment for an acute episode. Usually this involved turning up at a hospital emergency department. For most of the people in our study hospital admission followed the emergency department presentation.
However, not all people with severe asthma had been hospitalised.
The quick decisive action taken in the emergency department helped to reassure
Marea.
> Click here to view the transcript
They took my details and she made the comment “I can hear you wheezing, sit down there and we will get you straight in” which they did I was in there within 5 minutes. And they put me, like did all my observations, checked everything, and put me on a nebuliser, gave me some more Ventolin and Seretide and that sort of thing and I stayed there for about 3 or 4 hours and they sent me home and said not to come to work for the next couple of days. But I felt like I could the next day, but I did what they said. Yeah so I did have a really good outcome once the nebuliser was on and yea I felt my chest wasn’t as tight, and probably I think it’s very it’s reassuring that you’re in ED it’s a good place to be if you have any asthma attack so I think, yea, the reassurance probably calms you down.
For some people with severe asthma their experience was dismissed at emergency triage and other stages of the hospitalisation process. People with severe asthma explained that they know their disease and their signs and symptoms may not necessarily be what medical staff learn or read in text books.
Kim is frustrated that the doctors don’t read her lengthy file.
> Click here to view the transcript
I think the nurses are good and some doctors that are really good but at the moment there’s some doctors that aren’t really good. They don’t know what they’re doing and that doesn’t just apply to me. That applies to a few people. I think sometimes they probably should take a little bit longer in reading. I have a full folder in reading the notes rather than to let me struggle for a couple of hours not trying to work out what to do, or what not to do because they’ve never dealt with something like that before.
It is known that a small proportion of people with severe exacerbations of asthma either stop breathing or are at risk of stopping breathing, which is life-threatening and needs artificial mechanical ventilation via a breathing tube attached to a ventilator. People we talked to explained that some treatments could only be accessed in hospitals, such as intravenous infusions. As not all services are available at all hospitals, some people in the study had to be transferred from the original hospital they presented to for ongoing care.
Jemma has been hospitalised many times for severe asthma and has been ventilated.
> Click here to view the transcript
Well at least five times a year. I’d say maybe 35 times since I’ve had severe asthma and I’ve been ventilated maybe five times, six times.
The last time I went I was really sick I was put into the unit, the emergency and I stayed there for a very short time and they took me up to intensive care and by that stage I was not breathing so well and they put me on a BiPAP mask. And they kept me in for 24 hours in ICU.
In terms of the overall hospital experience itself, there was a range of experiences ‑ some people simply didn’t like being there, whilst others appreciated the “safety net” if anything went wrong.
Tony was happy with the nursing care he received but just hates hospitals.
> Click here to view the transcript
I hate being in hospitals. I don’t like being there at all. I think they’re ah awful place to stay. I mean I don’t… I mean they’re good service, they’re good nurses, I wouldn’t say anything about the staff there but I just hate being in them, you know. It’s not my cup of tea at all.
Frank feels safe in the hospital.
> Click here to view the transcript
I know people don’t like hospitals but I felt safe in the hospital. I was, mainly in the first stages I come home and I said oh gee, am I alright to be here at home? I wasn’t, it’s the uncertainty of being out of hospital in the event that something happens quickly whereas you know when you’re in hospital you feel safer because there’s backup at your fingertips. So it was just that little apprehensive move back home without the support group behind you. And that’s what I was missing. But couple of days later I was alright. It just, it was just like you know the Charlie Brown effect with the safety of the blanket.
Karen was allowed to manage her own medications.
> Click here to view the transcript
Because when I was in hospital they actually get me signed off so I can actually do my own meds. Because I’m faster at it, because I take so many, and I’m better at it, cause the nurses used to kind of go, what is the Theo-phy-line and, I’d go Theophylline, Nuelin 300 mgs BD, it’s, like it works on the smooth muscle in my lungs, so. And then they just go, how about you do your own meds? I go, it sounds good.
At times
Monique did not see the staff as attentive or supportive, and with no treatment changes happening, why stay in the hospital?
> Click here to view the transcript
And I pressed the nurse’s button and nobody came. And this was half my problem, is nobody seemed to get when I was in hospital that I literally go from you’re breathing OK, to you are now having a severe asthma attack and you can’t do anything.
And I said are you going to do anything different while I’m here if I stay the weekend and next week? And he was like, what do you mean? And I said, are you going to try a new medication, are you going to try mixing things up, like is anything going to change in my treatment by staying here? And he said, oh no, we’ll just monitor you. And I said, well then, I’ll go home because nebulizers I can give myself because that’s all you’re doing. And they were like, OK. And off I went.
Some people with severe asthma did not see the hospital as being helpful in their recovery. They mentioned the possibility of infection, as well as allergens such as cleaning agents and perfumes applied by the staff.
Jemma reacted to certain common items and ended up in a single room.
> Click here to view the transcript
They moved me out onto the third floor and somebody decided to use bleach and I almost ended up back in intensive care, so they moved me to another room. And then the nurse came in with… they were specialling another patient in the room. There was only two of us in the room and she had a perfume on that I was allergic to. So she went out of the room and told them, and they moved me to a single room where I stayed the rest of my time having tests and being put on the nebuliser.
Some people in the study only experienced hospitals as outpatients, preferring to be managed at a clinic, but appreciated that the hospital was there ‘in case’.
Michael found the clinic to be a happy medium.
> Click here to view the transcript
I’m thinking of cases in the city where I found out a clinic actually had a Ventolin machine there, and it was specifically for people like me who just found that the heat and the humidity, the pressure was just too much. And I just couldn’t look after myself well enough, but I didn’t want to go to hospital, to an ED, so you just go to a clinic and the nurses and the doctors there were fine and they got to know me and it wasn’t a problem.
Jemma feels supported at the clinic.
> Click here to view the transcript
I still go twice a week to hospital for a couple of hours each day. So there’s still that, what I’m going to say, sense of support still there. I’m still at home and I’m like my own person, I can do what I want to do but I still have a little bit of a thread, attachment so that if anything does go wrong, you know I can just pop in and just say, you know ‘this is how I’m feeling’. But, yeah, I mean I’ve got appointment with everybody. Within three weeks of coming out I’ve got four appointments. I really have a good, like, safety net.